Site information is static: write it properly at tender
Dr Stuart Kings
NEC4 Drafter & Co-author
PhD, MRICS, MCIPS, BSc (Hons)
The Scope can change throughout an NEC4 contract. The Site Information cannot. Whatever is written at tender decides the physical conditions risk for the life of the project.
A document that never moves
One of the golden rules of the NEC4 ECC, as Dr Stuart Kings, one of the nine drafters of NEC4, explained at Sypro’s Knowledge Hub webinar on 10 November, is that the Scope can be changed by the Project Manager under clause 14.3. Work can be added, omitted or altered throughout the contract.
The Site Information is different. “The site information isn’t changed,” Stuart said. “It’s static from the tender stage.” Whatever it contains when the contract is signed is the information against which every physical conditions compensation event will be judged.
Why it matters so much
Under clause 60.2, in judging physical conditions the contractor is assumed to have taken into account the Site Information, publicly available information referred to in it, information obtainable from a visual inspection of the Site, and other information an experienced contractor could reasonably be expected to have or obtain.
Two consequences follow. First, if a condition is described in the Site Information, an experienced contractor is expected to have allowed for it. Second, publicly available information only counts if the Site Information points to it. As Stuart put it, the client cannot later argue that a record sat in a local library and the contractor should have found it: “It’s got to be referred to from the site information.”
Clause 60.3 adds a further protection for the contractor. If the Site Information is ambiguous or inconsistent, the contractor is assumed to have taken into account the physical conditions more favourable to doing the work. Poorly drafted Site Information therefore tends to move risk back to the client.
What good Site Information contains
The NEC guidance, in Volume 2, sets out what the Site Information should cover as a minimum. Stuart summarised it at the webinar:
The location of the Site, clearly defined.
Reports and surveys, such as ground investigations, which may be extensive and are referenced from the Site Information.
Publicly available information referred to, for example archives or historic records.
Buried services, pipes and other objects in the ground, including any known voids or caves.
Structures and buildings adjacent to the Site that could affect access or the works.
Health and safety information.
These headings can be subdivided or extended for each project. Stuart’s advice was that clients should provide as much information as they possibly can. The more the contractor knows, the less is left to argument.
The deemed site visit
The contractor is assumed to have visited the Site. Stuart’s example of a headroom barrier on a jetty, not mentioned in the Site Information but visible on any visit, shows how much that assumption matters. Clients should make sure tenderers genuinely have the opportunity to inspect. Where access is restricted, for security or operational reasons, the assumption becomes harder to apply fairly, and the Site Information needs to do more of the work.
Clients should also think about timing. A short tender period can make a meaningful site visit difficult, particularly on large or complex sites, yet the contract still assumes the inspection took place. Allowing enough time, organising accompanied visits and recording what tenderers were shown all help to make the assumption fair, and they leave both parties with a clear record if a dispute arises later.
Information an experienced contractor would obtain
The final assumption is the most open ended. Stuart suggested a practical test: what information would the contractor gather if it were carrying out a speculative development on its own account? On a London Docklands site, for example, an experienced contractor would be expected to check for unexploded wartime ordnance.
Clients should not rely on this to fill gaps. It is subjective by nature, and a dispute about what an experienced contractor would have obtained is exactly the kind of argument good Site Information prevents.
No warranty, but real consequences
The standard NEC4 ECC does not warrant the accuracy of the Site Information, and some clients add Z clauses limiting reliance on it. That does not change the fundamental point. Under clauses 60.2 and 60.3, the quality of the Site Information directly shapes who carries the risk of what is found in the ground.
Commentators have long advised clients against accepting standard positions without understanding them. As CMS put it in a review of ground conditions risk across the standard forms: “Do not accept a standard form position without being aware of the consequences.”
A tender stage discipline
For clients and their advisers, the action is simple. Use the Volume 2 guidance and its template, gather the surveys and records you hold, reference the public sources you want the contractor to consider, and check the document for ambiguity before issue. Once the contract is signed, there is no second chance.
Sources
Pinsent Masons, Allocating the risk of physical conditions under NEC4 construction contracts (February 2025). https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/analysis/allocating-the-risk-of-physical-conditions-in-nec4
CMS, Stuck in the mud: are you responsible for unforeseen ground conditions? (November 2011). https://cms.law/en/gbr/legal-updates/stuck-in-the-mud-are-you-responsible-for-unforeseen-ground-conditions
Speaker quotes: Dr Stuart Kings, Sypro Knowledge Hub webinar, 10 November 2026.