Deleting 60.1(12) is not enough: Z clauses, the index and additional compensation events
Dr Stuart Kings
NEC4 Drafter & Co-author
PhD, MRICS, MCIPS, BSc (Hons)
Clients often amend the physical conditions and weather clauses. Done carelessly, it creates the disputes NEC4 is designed to avoid. There are better tools.
A common and costly instinct
The physical conditions and weather clauses are among the most frequently amended parts of NEC4. Dr Stuart Kings, one of the nine drafters of NEC4, told Sypro’s Knowledge Hub webinar on 10 November that he regularly sees clients make the risk “even harsher by adding in Z clauses”, either altering the definitions or deleting them entirely. His view: “I think that is overly harsh, personally, because that is significant risk for the contractor.”
CECA’s bulletin on Z clauses that alter risk profiles spells out the effect. Deleting compensation event 12 means that “all ground conditions would be Contractor risk”. Deleting event 13 makes all weather contractor risk.
The price of shifting risk
Shifting risk does not remove it. The contractor prices it. Stuart warned that the tender “will come back, obviously, more expensive, as will every compensation event affected by physical conditions.” Because the contractor carries its base risk into every quotation, a harsher allocation makes every change during the contract dearer too.
CECA adds that contractors may price the extra risk heavily or decline to bid if it becomes too uncertain. A client that deletes 60.1(12) to save money may find it has paid for that risk several times over.
The clauses are connected
The more technical danger is that NEC4 clauses interlock. Delete one and others are left hanging. Stuart’s example was a client that deletes clause 60.1(12) to place all physical conditions risk on the contractor. Other clauses deal with how physical conditions are judged, including the assumptions about Site Information and site inspection, and they only make sense alongside the compensation event. Deleting one clause and not the others leaves provisions with nothing to operate on, and that inconsistency can itself lead to dispute. As Stuart warned, “if you delete one clause and not another, that could cause further problems and could lead to dispute.”
His practical tip is one many users overlook: the index at the back of every NEC4 contract. It shows how clauses link to one another. Looking up physical conditions shows every clause that would need to be dealt with in a complete amendment. “This kind of principle holds firm for any amendment or Z clause that you’d wish to make,” he said. “Have a look at the index.”
Practitioners drafted it for a reason
Stuart reminded the webinar that NEC was drafted by practitioners and then vetted by lawyers, not the other way round. Amendments rarely receive the same scrutiny. CECA’s earlier bulletin on Z clauses makes the same point: amended wording may alter the risk profile more than intended, and once the contract is signed, the amendments are fixed.
The UK Government’s Construction Playbook sets standard forms as the starting point for public works. It does not forbid amendments, but it does say that bespoke clauses which do not apply to the specific project should not be incorporated.
A fairer tool: additional compensation events
NEC4 offers a better route for project specific risks. Additional compensation events can be stated in the Contract Data and become the 21st reason for a compensation event. They were present in NEC2, removed in NEC3 and restored in NEC4.
Stuart gave an example from tender negotiation. A contractor demolishing a 1960s school tells the client that, in its experience, such buildings always contain asbestos, so it has allowed £100,000 and a week in its programme. The client believes there is none. Rather than let the contractor price the risk, or argue about it later, the client adds an additional compensation event for the discovery of asbestos. The tender falls by £100,000, the programme shortens by a week, and if asbestos is found, it is a compensation event. As Stuart put it, “that’s a much fairer way of defining risk allocation.”
The parties can also agree rates or lump sums for such events at tender, rather than relying on forecast cost when they occur.
Get the wording right
Additional compensation events still need careful drafting. Stuart warned that he has known “loads of projects” add wording that seemed clear at tender but was interpreted differently once the project was live. His advice was to take legal support on both sides so the wording “can’t be twisted or interpreted differently” after signing.
Assessments are final
There is a final reason to get risk allocation right at the outset. Once a compensation event has been assessed, NEC4 does not allow the assessment to be revisited simply because the forecast proved wrong. It can only be changed by an agreement between the parties under clause 12.3, or through formal dispute resolution. For uncertain risks such as ground conditions and weather, clear allocation at tender is worth far more than argument afterwards.
Amend with purpose
None of this means clients should never amend NEC4. It means every amendment should have a clear objective, be checked against the index, be drafted with care and be priced with eyes open. Where a specific risk needs special treatment, an additional compensation event is usually fairer, clearer and cheaper than deleting a core clause.
Sources
CECA, NEC Bulletin No. 38: Z Clauses That Could Alter Risk Profile (February 2024). https://www.ceca.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/CECA-NEC-Bulletin-No.-38-Z-Clauses-That-Could-Alter-Risk-Profile-February-2024.pdf
CECA, NEC4 Bulletin No. 1: Amended Contracts and Z Clauses (January 2021). https://gmhplanning.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CECA-NEC4-Bulletin-No.1-Z-clauses.pdf
Trowers & Hamlins, The Construction Playbook: standardising contracts (August 2021). https://trowers.com/insights/2021/august/the-construction-playbook—standardising-contracts
Speaker quotes: Dr Stuart Kings, Sypro Knowledge Hub webinar, 10 November 2026.