Newsworthy weather: why most bad weather is not a compensation event
Dr Stuart Kings
NEC4 Drafter & Co-author
PhD, MRICS, MCIPS, BSc (Hons)
Clause 60.1(13) of NEC4 treats weather as a matter of statistics, not discomfort. Understanding the test explains why so few weather claims succeed, and why the bar is rising.
A scientific test in a subjective industry
Most site teams can tell you when the weather has been bad. Fewer can tell you whether it has been bad enough to be a compensation event under NEC4. The answer is set by clause 60.1(13), and it is deliberately objective.
At Sypro’s Knowledge Hub webinar on 10 November, Dr Stuart Kings, one of the nine drafters of NEC4, described the clause as “in some respects, quite brutal and quite, scientific, in its definition”. His conclusion will surprise anyone who has watched a programme slip through a wet winter: for the weather to qualify, “it would have to be, I would suggest, kind of newsworthy weather, you know, so anything on the news, like the Beast from the East… run of the mill weather would not constitute a compensation event.”
What the clause actually requires
A weather compensation event requires a weather measurement to be recorded within a calendar month, before the Completion Date for the whole of the works, and at the place stated in the Contract Data. The value recorded must be one which the weather data shows occurs, on average, less frequently than once in ten years.
The standard weather measurements are narrow. CECA’s NEC bulletin on assessing weather delays lists the four in the Contract Data: cumulative rainfall, the number of days with rainfall of more than 5mm, the number of days with a minimum air temperature below zero, and the number of days with snow lying at a stated time, typically 0900. Anything else, such as wind, heat or fog, only counts if it has been added.
Even when the threshold is passed, the contractor is not compensated for the whole event. Only the difference between the recorded measurement and the 1 in 10 year value is taken into account. The 1 in 10 year value is the contractor’s base risk, carried into the contract and into every compensation event priced during it.
How the 1 in 10 year value is set
The weather data is usually supplied by the Met Office. Its construction guidance describes the 1 in 10 year value as a return period, “the worst case scenario one may experience every ten years”, calculated from at least thirty years of records. As Stuart explained, the practical effect is that the benchmark is typically the third worst reading in thirty years, which gives a more reliable figure than the last ten years alone.
The Met Office also offers reports that compare a month’s actual conditions with the long term average and the 1 in 10 year value. CECA notes that these monthly reports are typically issued within a week of month end, which means the evidence for a weather compensation event is available quickly if the team knows to ask for it.
A worked example
Stuart described a compensation event he assessed for snow in December 2010. The weather data came from an air force base. The contractor recorded fourteen days with snow lying at 0900. The 1 in 10 year value for December was ten days. The extra over was therefore four days.
That was not the end of the analysis. Each of those four days still had to be tested. Were they working days? Was the work being carried out that day affected by snow? A Saturday, or a day spent on internal finishes, would not count. The first ten days, of course, were contractor risk regardless.
Why the bar keeps rising
There is a further twist. The 1 in 10 year value is drawn from historic records, and those records increasingly include extreme events. As Stuart put it, “all that sporadic weather is going into that averaging.” The more often severe weather occurs, the higher the threshold climbs, and the rarer a qualifying compensation event becomes.
The Met Office guide notes that its 1 in 10 year figures are currently drawn from data running up to 2010, and CECA flags that updated datasets were expected. Either way, the trend is the same: ordinary bad weather, however disruptive, is priced risk.
Why contractors still like the clause
For all its severity, Stuart reported that contractors often favour this definition. It is measurable. A contractor can look at the data, calculate the exposure and decide how much of it to price. That contrasts with the “exceptionally adverse” wording found in other forms, which Stuart called “just a recipe for potential dispute.”
The clause trades generosity for certainty. Both parties can know, with data, whether a compensation event has occurred.
What this means in practice
For contractors, price weather as a real risk. Use the Met Office planning averages at tender, build realistic weather working days into the programme and do not assume that a bad month will be recoverable.
For clients and Project Managers, recognise that pushing more weather risk onto the contractor is not free. It returns as higher tender prices, longer programmes and more expensive compensation events, because the contractor carries the same base weather risk into every quotation.
For both, request the Met Office report for any month that looks borderline, record the activities affected on each day, and keep the evidence in one auditable place. When a genuine event does occur, the strength of the claim will rest on that record.
Sources
CECA, NEC Bulletin No. 48: Assessing weather delays under NEC contracts (December 2024). https://ceca.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/CECA-NEC-Bulletin-Nr-48-Assessing-weather-delays-under-NEC-contracts-December-2024.pdf
Met Office, Construction catalogue guide: Planning Averages and Downtime Summary Reports. https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/binaries/content/assets/metofficegovuk/pdf/business/sectors/construction-catalogue-guide-v2.pdf
Pinsent Masons, Navigating weather conditions in Hong Kong SAR NEC4 contracts (March 2025), which also summarises the standard NEC4 ECC weather test. https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/analysis/nec-risk-allocation-for-weather-events
Speaker quotes: Dr Stuart Kings, Sypro Knowledge Hub webinar, 10 November 2026.