Knowledge Hub

Splayed brick, diesel and secret tunnels: judging physical conditions in practice

20 November 2026

Dr Stuart Kings

NEC4 Drafter & Co-author

PhD, MRICS, MCIPS, BSc (Hons)

Construction workers consulting a tablet
5 minutes read

Clause 60.1(12) asks what an experienced contractor would have allowed for. Real examples show where that line falls, and why it will always need judgment.

 

A subjective clause by necessity

Weather under NEC4 is measured. Physical conditions are judged. Clause 60.1(12) makes physical conditions within the Site a compensation event only where an experienced contractor would have judged, at the Contract Date, that they had such a small chance of occurring that it would have been unreasonable to allow for them. Only the difference between the conditions encountered and those it would have been reasonable to allow for is taken into account.

Dr Stuart Kings, one of the nine drafters of NEC4, was candid about this at Sypro’s Knowledge Hub webinar on 10 November. Asked why the contract is not better written, he said: “I don’t think it can be in this area… So I think the clause is fair. But always the interpretation is going to be, subjective, and we need to be really pragmatic.”

 

The tests in brief

The condition must be physical and within the boundary of the Site. Stuart noted that a landslip on an access road away from the Site would not qualify. It cannot be weather, which has its own clause.

The test is applied to an experienced contractor in that type of work, whatever the actual contractor’s experience. And clause 60.2 adds four assumptions: the contractor is taken to have considered the Site Information, publicly available information referred to in it, information obtainable from a visual inspection of the Site, and other information an experienced contractor could reasonably be expected to have or obtain.

Pinsent Masons notes that the NEC test is one of probability rather than foreseeability: a condition need not be unforeseeable, only unlikely enough that it was reasonable not to allow for it.

 

Victorian housing and splayed brick foundations

A contractor demolishes a Victorian housing estate and finds splayed brick foundations rather than concrete. Stuart’s view was that this is to be expected, “because that’s how the Victorians built”. An experienced contractor in that line of work would have allowed for it. Not a compensation event.

 

Diesel on a former petrol station

A residential scheme on a disused petrol station uncovers fuel contamination. A couple of cubic metres is exactly what an experienced contractor would expect on such a site. But if the whole site proves to be saturated, Stuart argued there is a tipping point beyond which the contamination could not reasonably have been expected, unless the Site Information said otherwise. Only the extra over would be the compensation event.

This example shows the hardest part of the clause. Deciding where the base level ends and the extra over begins is, in Stuart’s words, “notoriously difficult”.

 

The headroom barrier on the jetty

A contractor was engaged to repoint a stone quay at low tide, reached by driving large plant down a jetty. On arrival, the plant could not pass a headroom barrier. The barrier was not mentioned in the Site Information, but it had always been there. It was obtainable from a visual inspection, so the contractor was assumed to have known about it. Not a compensation event, provided the contractor had been given the opportunity to visit.

 

Secret tunnels on a nuclear site

On a nuclear site, a contractor found tunnels thought to date from the Second World War. People familiar with the site knew of them, but they were never shown on any plan. Stuart’s judgment: “it would be a bit rich to say the contractor should have assumed and taken account of the secret tunnels.” The excavation and backfilling became a compensation event.

The deemed visual inspection also has limits. Where a site is secure or operational and the client does not allow a visit, it would be unfair to assume the contractor saw what it could not.

 

Unlocking the grey areas

Because judgment is unavoidable, process matters. Stuart recommended collaborative working during the quotation period, extending the periods for quoting and assessment where needed, and bringing in an independent ground conditions expert early. If agreement still cannot be reached, the senior representatives procedure in Option W2 offers a structured, without prejudice step before adjudication. Physical conditions, he suggested, are one of the most common issues likely to reach that stage.

For projects with significant groundworks, some clients go further and define baseline ground conditions in the contract, so that anything worse than the baseline is client risk. That reduces the room for argument, provided the baseline is drafted carefully.

 

Pragmatism, not pedantry

The examples share a pattern. Where a condition is typical of the site, the risk is priced. Where it is genuinely beyond what an experienced contractor would anticipate, the client pays the extra over. Teams that approach the clause with that common sense, and keep good records of what was encountered, tend to settle physical conditions quickly. Teams that do not, end up in front of an adjudicator.

 

Sources

Pinsent Masons, Allocating the risk of physical conditions under NEC4 construction contracts (February 2025). https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/analysis/allocating-the-risk-of-physical-conditions-in-nec4

CMS, Stuck in the mud: are you responsible for unforeseen ground conditions? (November 2011). https://cms.law/en/gbr/legal-updates/stuck-in-the-mud-are-you-responsible-for-unforeseen-ground-conditions

CECA, NEC Bulletin No. 38: Z Clauses That Could Alter Risk Profile (February 2024). https://www.ceca.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/CECA-NEC-Bulletin-No.-38-Z-Clauses-That-Could-Alter-Risk-Profile-February-2024.pdf

Speaker quotes: Dr Stuart Kings, Sypro Knowledge Hub webinar, 10 November 2026.

 

 

Meet the author Dr Stuart Kings

NEC4 Drafter & Co-author

PhD, MRICS, MCIPS, BSc (Hons)
View Profile
Share

Get started now with Sypro

Related articles